Skip Navigation

RmDebArc_5

@ RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works

帖子

105
评论

258
加入于

2 yr. ago

Mastodon: @[email protected] Piefed: @[email protected]

4个月前

Scratch a liberal/social democrat...
跳过
RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works 4个月前

4个月前

Scratch a liberal/social democrat...

跳过

RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works 4个月前

4个月前

Scratch a liberal/social democrat...

跳过

RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works 4个月前

@[email protected]

I know the post is like a month old, but the topic came up in a discussion and I couldn’t find a source for the quote and was wondering if you could share a link or something

linuxmemes @lemmy.world

RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works

5个月前

Alpaca flatpack app

跳过

RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works 5个月前

I have made good experiences with GPT4ALL

5个月前

Germany urges Apple and Google to remove DeepSeek from app stores over EU privacy concerns

跳过

RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works 5个月前

AFAIK per EU law the collected data has to stay in data centers in the EU, ChatGPT and Gemini at least pretend to conform while Deepseek explicitly states that the data is stored in Chinese data centers.

5个月前

Scratch a liberal/social democrat...

跳过

RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works 5个月前

Regarding the edit: you should probably add that to your first comment as you probably meant the starter of this thread and not me

Using the political compass wasn’t ideal to get my point across (I know it’s flawed, just didn’t know how to say it better). Basically what I meant is that on a scale from social democracy to anarcho-communism socialism+democracy would be something of a middle ground if that makes sense.

Regarding state socialism/capitalism: I know there is a distinction and my insertion wasn’t very nuanced, that’s why I formulated it as possibility.

Anyway thanks for the nice discussion, it’s always to have a discussion that is based on arguments and not insults

5个月前

Scratch a liberal/social democrat...

跳过

RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works 5个月前

The way you describe it makes sense to me. The main problem in Germany was probably not directly going to socialism after WW1, especially since Germany somewhat was expected to directly go there from monarchy (I believe this prediction was made in the communist manifesto? Not sure). Even though it doesn’t fit my ideals, Weimar may have been more stable if an authoritarian socialist government was installed, as a lot of people were anti democratic.

Sorry if my statements seemed in bad faith, but I find it hard discussing Marxist-Leninist politics on Lemmy, as those defending those parties/states are a lot of times Lemmygrad style stalinists.

I asked about rule 3 as I and most people I personally know use the democratic socialism definition in that capitalism is inherently incompatible with democracy, and that one should thus strive for a socialist society using any means possible (including a revolution). This society would then be organized via a representative democracy.

What you described is what I would describe as social democracy and nothing else, however after looking it up a bit these terms are defined so broadly that there is significant overlap between definitions. I fear this is a major problem with these kind of terms as everyone has their own definitions of them/uses them differently creating confusion.

I think socialism is inherently a related idea to democracy (one could argue socialism without some form of democracy or decentralized government isn’t socialism but state capitalism) and together they are the “conservative” variant of anarcho communism.

5个月前

Scratch a liberal/social democrat...

跳过

RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works 5个月前

I am not trying to say that the SPD wasn’t defending capitalism at the time, heck one could argue during World War One they were even defending the monarchy. What my point is, is that the KPD in fighting the SPD (who I’d argue was still the major party politically closest to the KPD, even if there were significant differences) as their main political enemy and not the openly fascist NSDAP or one of the party’s who openly called for a return to a monarchy they became more like the NSDAP (Führerkult, antisemitism, authoritarian etc) and thus I argue that neither of these were good options and one shouldn’t have have voted for neither of them. I’m not saying the saying the SPD isn’t problematic from a communist perspective, but that one shouldn’t just give the KPD a pass because they are communists. This coming from a anarcho communist standpoint, so I understand if you aren’t as uncomfortable with a authoritarian party, but that’s just my view on the matter.

Also, one question regarding rule 3, I get all of the listed things but could you specify what exactly you mean with Democratic Socialism. Is this about reformist socialist parties or about revolutionaries who want a democratically organized socialism?

5个月前

Scratch a liberal/social democrat...

跳过

RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works 5个月前

Say about the SPD what you want, but the KPD also betrayed communism in a way.

Firstly, like you mentioned, the fight against the SPD instead of NSDAP, the party which would have been the most realistic to establish socialism with
The antisemitism and nazi rhetoric present in their campaigns, with slogans like “Nieder mit Judenrepublik“ - “ Down with the Jewish Republic” and calling for violence against Jews
The forced unification of the party und the Führer like Figur of Ernst Thälmann

I am not going to discuss whether their idea of how a transitionary socialist society should look is “korrekt”, however the devotion to Stalins ideas and the exclusion of parts of the because they were to left should be looked at critically.

One thing in regard to the SPD: Originally it was called Socialist Workers Party of Germany, however it was banned for being socialist. After the law banning them went out of power, they “restarted” as SPD, likely because they wanted to avoid being banned again. In the beginning the SPD was quite Marxist and the social democrats in the party were more of a minority despite the name. There also had been significant efforts to deradicalise the SPD by conservatives, for example by giving SPD functionaries roles in government without them being able to make radical changes, slowly turning the party from Kommunist to Socialist to Social democracy to the conservative party it is today. I don’t know who, it may have been Trotsky, but a communist revolutionary has argued that parties trying to reform capitalism to socialism via a representative democracy will always fail due to always either being not radical enough or not mayor enough

5个月前

What is your most useful Linux app which others might not know about (please don't just give the name but a link and why it is good for you) ?

跳过

RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works 5个月前

Is there any concern to be had with archive warrior regarding legality (like scraping piracy sites)?

Lefty Memes @lemmy.dbzer0.com

RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works

6个月前

Karl

9个月前

Will wine ever be able to run anticheat?

跳过

RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works 9个月前

At that point you might as well not have a kernel level anti cheat and companies who insist on kernel level anti cheat will block wine. The only solutions I see are

Developers mainly use server side anti cheat
They make native Linux games
Distros provide a way to ensure a untainted (signed) kernel

9个月前

Notion alternatives? How suitable is to use a database instead?

跳过

RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works 9个月前

Obsidian is proprietary though

9个月前

YSK You can browse, upvote, reply, follow and post on Lemmy using a Mastodon account. Short guide.

跳过

RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works 9个月前

kbin has been discontinued but there is a fork called mbin, piefed and loops are missing and some very small projects, also bridgyfed isn’t there but it’s still a pretty good overview

9个月前

YSK You can browse, upvote, reply, follow and post on Lemmy using a Mastodon account. Short guide.

跳过

RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works 9个月前

Yes, and there are already lots of different ones that, at least partially, work together:

Don’t know if there is something LinkedIn like though

9个月前

Is CruchyRoll still the 'best' paid anime streaming service to use in the U.S.?

跳过

RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works 9个月前

AFAIK they bought their only real competition (funimation). Regarding recommendations: I personally find piracy streaming sites have the best recommendations, I mostly use them just for recommendations and don’t even watch there, also you could take a look at [email protected], specifically the recommendation threads

9个月前

Some questions before probably getting a Steam Deck

跳过

RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works 9个月前

Just FYI while it uses X11 in desktop mode, in game mode it uses Wayland. It’s probably still on 5.X because for the main use case of the deck plasma 6 isn’t really that much of an upgrade and they probably prefer having a stable system than having some new stuff most users won’t actually use

9个月前

Some questions before probably getting a Steam Deck

跳过

RmDebArc_5 @sh.itjust.works 9个月前

It’s pretty much impossible to get gnome on regular steamOS. Bazzite also has some additional stuff compared to steamOS, namely printing support, optional full disk encryption, newer plasma version (SteamOS should be on 5.27 or what ever the latest version of plasma 5 is). Nothing major, but small stuff. Bazzite has the disadvantage of not being installed by default and less of a backing (Valve still is a big company). Most things on steam deck are easily replaceable, except for the battery, but not necessarily upgradable. If you want to upgrade storage be aware that the steam deck uses a relatively rare nvme size, so prizes might be higher than expected (other than that it’s quite simple). The screen also can be upgraded but that requires a sizable amount of work, same with ram.